Petrol Station Insurance Checklist: 15 Things to Check Before You Renew

check your sums insured, business interruption period, pollution cover, what's declared about your site, your security and testing conditions, and your claims record. Start 60 to 90 days before renewal so there's time to compare options properly.

11/2/20266 min read

a row of gas pumps sitting in a parking lot
a row of gas pumps sitting in a parking lot

Forecourt Cover is a trading name of Full-Time Cover Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 766466).

Renewal time is when most petrol station owners look at price. It's also the best moment to check that your cover still matches your site, because a forecourt that has changed since last year (a new shop unit, an EV charger, extended opening hours, a refurbished canopy) can end up with a policy that no longer fits.

This checklist covers the 15 things we'd review before renewing a petrol station insurance policy. Use it to review your current cover, to question your broker or insurer, or to prepare for a market comparison.

When should you start your petrol station insurance renewal?

Ideally 60 to 90 days before your renewal date. That gives you time to gather information, review the renewal terms and, if needed, ask a broker to approach other insurers. Leaving it to the last week limits your options and can mean accepting whatever you're offered.

The 15-point petrol station insurance renewal checklist

1. Check your buildings sum insured

Is the sum insured based on a realistic rebuild cost, not market value or last year's figure? Construction costs change, and if you're under-insured, insurers can reduce what they pay on a claim. Ask when your rebuild value was last properly assessed. Include the shop, canopy, pump islands, tanks, pipework and forecourt surfacing.

2. Review your stock and fuel values

Check both shop stock and fuel stock. Fuel is often your largest stock value and it moves with price and delivery patterns. Make sure the limit reflects your peak position, not an average.

3. Check your business interruption cover and indemnity period

This is one of the most commonly under-insured areas. Ask yourself how long it would realistically take to rebuild, replace tanks or pumps, get regulatory sign-off and recommission the site. If your indemnity period is 12 months and a full rebuild would take 18, there's a gap. Also check your declared gross profit or revenue figure is up to date.

4. Confirm your pollution and environmental liability cover

Many standard commercial policies exclude or heavily limit pollution. Check:

  • Is there environmental or pollution cover at all?

  • Does it cover gradual leaks as well as sudden incidents?

  • Does it include clean-up costs and third-party claims?

  • Is the limit realistic for the potential cost of a contamination event?

If you can't find the answer in your policy documents, ask your broker to confirm in writing.

5. Check fuel misfuelling and cross-contamination cover

If the wrong fuel is delivered into a tank, or fuels mix, the loss can be significant. Check whether this is covered, what the limit is and what the excess is.

6. Review public and product liability limits

Check the limit of indemnity is appropriate for the number of people using your site each day. Make sure it applies to everything that happens on the forecourt, not just the shop, and that any services you offer (car wash, vacuum bays, tyre inflation) are included.

7. Check your employers' liability certificate

Employers' liability insurance is a legal requirement for most employers in the UK, with a minimum of £5 million of cover. Check the certificate is in date, the cover level is right and that it covers all your staff, including part-time and casual workers.

8. Update everything you've changed since last year

Insurers need to know about changes in your operation. Tell your broker if you've added or changed any of the following:

  • New shop areas, food-to-go or hot food

  • Car wash, jet wash or vacuum equipment

  • ATM or cash machines

  • EV charging points

  • New tanks, pumps or canopy works

  • Longer opening hours or 24-hour trading

  • Staff numbers or turnover

Failing to disclose a material change can create problems at claim stage.

9. Review your money and cash limits

Check your cash-in-premises, cash-in-transit and safe limits against what you really hold, especially on peak days and weekends. Check any conditions attached, such as safe specifications or banking frequency.

10. Check ATM and cash machine cover

If you host a cash machine, check who is responsible for the machine and its contents, whether damage from theft or ram-raid is covered and what security conditions apply.

11. Read the policy conditions and warranties

This is the section most owners skip. Look for conditions covering:

  • Security (CCTV, alarms, safes, lighting)

  • Fire protection and maintenance

  • Tank and pipework testing and leak detection

  • Record-keeping and inspections

If you can't meet a condition, a claim could be affected. Tell your broker so it can be amended or the requirement adjusted.

12. Review your claims record and any open claims

Check that your claims history is accurate in the insurer's records, and that any incidents you reported are recorded properly. Gather evidence of improvements you've made since a claim, such as new CCTV, better drainage or staff training, as it can support better renewal terms.

13. Check your excesses

Look at the excess on each section. Is there a very high excess on a type of claim that's common for you, such as small property damage or liability claims? A lower premium with a high excess may not be a saving if you end up paying out of pocket regularly.

14. Check optional covers you may need

Review whether any of these should be added:

  • Legal expenses

  • Goods in transit

  • Personal accident for employees

  • Cyber and card payment risks

  • EV charging equipment and associated liability

  • Terrorism cover

  • Loss of licence or loss of fuel supply contract protection (where available)

15. Compare the market, don't just accept the renewal

Renewal terms are rarely the best available simply by default. A specialist broker can approach insurers who have a real appetite for forecourt risk and compare like for like, including wording, not just price. Even if you stay with your current insurer, a comparison gives you a benchmark and often better terms.

Documents to gather before you renew

Having these ready makes the process faster and the quotes more accurate:

  • Current policy schedule and wording

  • Renewal invitation from your insurer

  • Latest buildings rebuild valuation

  • Stock and fuel stock figures

  • Wage roll and employee numbers

  • Annual turnover and gross profit figures

  • Tank and pipework test certificates and leak detection records

  • Fire protection and electrical inspection certificates

  • Security details (CCTV, alarm, safe, lighting)

  • Accident and incident log

  • Claims history for the last five years

  • Details of any changes to the site or operation

Common petrol station insurance renewal mistakes

  • Accepting the renewal without checking sums insured, which often rise slower than actual costs

  • Choosing on price alone without comparing wording, limits and exclusions

  • Not declaring changes to the site or services

  • Short business interruption periods that don't match a realistic rebuild timeline

  • Assuming pollution is covered without checking the policy

  • Ignoring conditions that could affect a claim

  • Leaving it too late, which limits your options

Why use a specialist broker at renewal?

Forecourt insurance is a specialist area. A broker who works with petrol stations every day knows which insurers want your type of risk, where policy wording commonly falls short and how to present your site in the best light. At Forecourt Cover we review your existing cover, explain any gaps in plain English and compare terms across our panel of insurers.

Get a free renewal review

Send us your current policy schedule and renewal terms, and we'll tell you what we think of your cover and what's available on the market.

Email: hello@forecourtcover.co.uk Phone: 020 7923 4191 [Request a renewal review] (button linking to /contact)

For a full overview of what forecourt cover includes, see our petrol station insurance guide, and for what drives your premium, read our guide to petrol station insurance cost.

Frequently asked questions

When should I renew my petrol station insurance?

Start reviewing 60 to 90 days before your renewal date. This gives you time to check your cover, gather information and compare options rather than accepting whatever is offered at the last minute.

What should I check on my petrol station insurance renewal?

Check your sums insured for buildings, stock and fuel, your business interruption period, pollution and environmental cover, liability limits, policy conditions, any changes to your site, your excesses and whether you need any additional covers.

Can I change my petrol station insurance provider at renewal?

Yes. You're free to move insurers at renewal, and a broker can approach the market for you. Make sure any new policy starts before your old one ends so there's no gap in cover.

What happens if I don't tell my insurer about changes to my forecourt?

Failing to disclose a material change, such as a new service, longer opening hours or an EV charger, can affect a claim. In some cases the insurer may reduce or refuse a payment, so it's important to tell your broker or insurer about changes as they happen and at renewal.

Is the renewal price the best price I can get?

Not necessarily. Renewal terms reflect your current insurer's pricing, not the wider market. Comparing options through a specialist broker gives you a benchmark and can lead to better terms or better cover.

How long should my business interruption cover last on a petrol station?

It should match the realistic time needed to rebuild, replace specialist equipment such as tanks and pumps, get approvals and reopen. Many owners underestimate this, so check your indemnity period against a realistic rebuild timeline with your broker.

Do I need to renew my employers' liability certificate each year?

Yes. Employers' liability is a legal requirement for most UK employers with a minimum of £5 million cover. You should check the certificate is current each year and that it covers all staff.

What documents do I need to renew my forecourt insurance?

Typically your current policy schedule, rebuild valuation, stock and fuel figures, wage roll, turnover, tank and pipework test records, fire and electrical certificates, security details, claims history and details of any changes to your site.

Forecourt Cover is a trading name of Full-Time Cover Limited, authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 766466). Registered in England and Wales, company number 09241439. Registered office: 3rd Floor, 8 Devonshire Square, London, EC2M 4PL. This article is general information, not personal advice.

Forecourt Cover is a licenced trading name of Full-Time Cover Limited and is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (766466) .Registered in England and Wales at 3rd Floor, 8 Devonshire Square, London, EC2M 4PL. Registered number: 09241439.

© 2025. All rights reserved.